Study shows fewer draws do not affect quality of care for critically ill
Intensive care unit doctors at St. Paul's Hospital in
Vancouver have done away with daily routine blood tests on patients without
affecting the quality of care, simply by challenging a long-held dictum that
those who are critically ill need to have blood drawn that frequently.
The prize-winning study of the widely accepted
hospital habit shows that the number of tests can be reduced "to lower
costs and free up nurses and lab personnel for more important things,"
according to Dr. Peter Dodek, the intensive care specialist who supervised a
group of five internal medicine residents in the study.
The group won a "best team" quality
improvement project award from the University of B.C. faculty of medicine. Its
results will be presented soon at a medical conference in Philadelphia.
Daily blood testing has, for many decades, been a
common hospital practice around the world. Routine blood draws are meant to
monitor such things as blood chemistry and red and white blood cell counts. But
recent studies here and elsewhere are showing that such tests are often a waste
of resources and can even lead to anemia in some patients, who might require
blood transfusions as a result.
In addition, every time a patient gets pricked,
there's a potential for infection.
The team of internal medicine residents, under the
supervision of Dodek, set out to reduce tests by at least 10 per cent,
comparing patients before the change and after.
In a sample of about 900 patients, the average age was
58 and most (about two thirds) were male. In the group that received daily
blood tests, the ICU death rate was 18 per cent; in the group that didn't
receive as many tests, the mortality rate was 20 per cent. The length of stay
was 4.3 days for ICU patients in the routine blood test group and 3.7 in the
group with fewer tests (the frequency of which varied, depending on need).
Dodek said the differences in outcomes between the study groups are not
statistically significant. That means that drawing less blood had no negative
effect on patients.
"We showed that better stewardship of health care
is possible, that there has to be a good reason for every test you do and we
can stop doing things we don't need to do. The reason for doing tests shouldn't
merely be that it's another day," he said in an interview.
To inform hospital staff about the change, education
sessions were held and posters were put up as reminders to reduce unnecessary
tests. Forms and checklists were also changed.
Kim Macfarlane, a clinical nurse specialist with
responsibility for eight ICUs across the Fraser Health region, said over the
past year practices in those hospitals have started changing, too, because of
evolving evidence that daily tests aren't necessary.
"We're trying to conserve patients' blood. We
know we don't need to collect so frequently because we have non-invasive
monitors, which also help us know what's going on," she said, adding
smaller collection tubes are also being used.
While baseline blood work on all newly admitted
patients is important, tests should only be ordered as conditions and symptoms
warrant, Macfarlane said. While Fraser Health hasn't done its own study, the
St. Paul's work helps reinforce confidence in the safety of the changes, she
said.
Dodek is widely recognized as a leader in quality
improvement, said Gavin Wilson, spokesman for Vancouver General Hospital.
"Our quality improvement group is looking at Peter's data and is in the
process of deciding if the cost/safety balance works for our patients," he
said.
Dodek said every blood collection costs at least $10
for materials and lab analysis. So doing 2,220 fewer tests in a year, which is
what St. Paul's achieved, meant cost savings of at least $22,000
Tomado de: vancouversun.com/health
Intensive care unit doctors at St. Paul's Hospital in
Vancouver have done away with daily routine blood tests on patients without
affecting the quality of care, simply by challenging a long-held dictum that
those who are critically ill need to have blood drawn that frequently.
The prize-winning study of the widely accepted
hospital habit shows that the number of tests can be reduced "to lower
costs and free up nurses and lab personnel for more important things,"
according to Dr. Peter Dodek, the intensive care specialist who supervised a
group of five internal medicine residents in the study.
The group won a "best team" quality
improvement project award from the University of B.C. faculty of medicine. Its
results will be presented soon at a medical conference in Philadelphia.
Daily blood testing has, for many decades, been a
common hospital practice around the world. Routine blood draws are meant to
monitor such things as blood chemistry and red and white blood cell counts. But
recent studies here and elsewhere are showing that such tests are often a waste
of resources and can even lead to anemia in some patients, who might require
blood transfusions as a result.
In addition, every time a patient gets pricked,
there's a potential for infection.
The team of internal medicine residents, under the
supervision of Dodek, set out to reduce tests by at least 10 per cent,
comparing patients before the change and after.
In a sample of about 900 patients, the average age was
58 and most (about two thirds) were male. In the group that received daily
blood tests, the ICU death rate was 18 per cent; in the group that didn't
receive as many tests, the mortality rate was 20 per cent. The length of stay
was 4.3 days for ICU patients in the routine blood test group and 3.7 in the
group with fewer tests (the frequency of which varied, depending on need).
Dodek said the differences in outcomes between the study groups are not
statistically significant. That means that drawing less blood had no negative
effect on patients.
"We showed that better stewardship of health care
is possible, that there has to be a good reason for every test you do and we
can stop doing things we don't need to do. The reason for doing tests shouldn't
merely be that it's another day," he said in an interview.
To inform hospital staff about the change, education
sessions were held and posters were put up as reminders to reduce unnecessary
tests. Forms and checklists were also changed.
Kim Macfarlane, a clinical nurse specialist with
responsibility for eight ICUs across the Fraser Health region, said over the
past year practices in those hospitals have started changing, too, because of
evolving evidence that daily tests aren't necessary.
"We're trying to conserve patients' blood. We
know we don't need to collect so frequently because we have non-invasive
monitors, which also help us know what's going on," she said, adding
smaller collection tubes are also being used.
While baseline blood work on all newly admitted
patients is important, tests should only be ordered as conditions and symptoms
warrant, Macfarlane said. While Fraser Health hasn't done its own study, the
St. Paul's work helps reinforce confidence in the safety of the changes, she
said.
Dodek is widely recognized as a leader in quality
improvement, said Gavin Wilson, spokesman for Vancouver General Hospital.
"Our quality improvement group is looking at Peter's data and is in the
process of deciding if the cost/safety balance works for our patients," he
said.
Dodek said every blood collection costs at least $10
for materials and lab analysis. So doing 2,220 fewer tests in a year, which is
what St. Paul's achieved, meant cost savings of at least $22,000